Skip to content
Balance Journal

Americano vs Long Black: The Ratio Is the Real Difference

Published 13 min read
James Bellis
James Bellis

Coffee Writer & Biohacker

Americano and Long Black coffees side-by-side in white cups, showing crema differences between the two espresso-based drinks

Some of the links in this article are affiliate links, which help fund our independent review work at no extra cost to you. How we assessed these products is explained in this article and our Editor Lab methodology. No brand pays to appear, and no placement is guaranteed.

An Americano and a long black are the same two ingredients, espresso and hot water, and the real difference is how much water you get, not which goes in first. You have probably read that it all comes down to pour order, and half the internet will tell you that stops mattering once you stir. The people who make these drinks for a living keep pointing somewhere else.

Both drinks are espresso and hot water, and neither has milk. A long black is a double shot of espresso poured onto about 100-120 ml of hot water, so the cup you get keeps its crema and tastes stronger. An Americano is espresso topped up with about 120-180 ml of hot water per shot, so the cup you get is milder and the crema breaks up.

Read any thread on the subject and you will see the pattern. Four of the six comments quoted below talk about shot style, drink size or the amount of water, not the order of the pour.

This guide uses the published definitions of both drinks, USDA caffeine data, and what working baristas report on r/barista and r/espresso, compared against what I taught as a barista trainer at UCC Coffee. If you want to pick up the same counter skills yourself, barista lessons in the UK are a sensible place to start.

Americano vs Long Black: The Short Answer

If you only want the facts, this table is the one to keep. Every figure in it comes from the published definitions of the two drinks.

What you getLong blackAmericano
Build orderEspresso poured into hot waterHot water added to the espresso
Typical shotsA double shotA single shot, more if you ask
Typical waterAbout 100-120 mlAbout 120-180 ml per shot
CremaIntact and more pronouncedLess pronounced, often broken up
TasteStronger and more concentratedMilder and more diluted

Pour order is the part everyone repeats, and it is real, but it comes second. The water ratio sets the strength you taste, and the pour order mostly decides what happens to the crema.

What Is a Long Black?

A long black is, according to Wikipedia, "a style of coffee commonly found in Australia and New Zealand, introduced in the 1950s and 1960s made by pouring a double shot of espresso into hot water." You can read that as espresso on water and nothing else.

The same entry puts the water at about 100-120 ml, or 4 ounces, and adds that "the measurement is amenable to individual taste." That small amount of water is why you taste more coffee.

A long black is not a milk drink and it is not a filter coffee. If you want milk in your cup, you are in a different family, and guides such as flat white vs latte, latte vs cappuccino, what is a macchiato, and what is a cortado cover those orders.

What Is an Americano?

When you order an Americano, you get espresso with hot water added, and Wikipedia's Caffè Americano entry describes it as "an espresso shot with hot water at a 1:3 to 1:4 ratio." The same entry says its strength "varies with the number of shots of espresso and the amount of water added."

For a single shot, that entry gives about 120-180 ml of hot water, and it cites my 2023 guide for that water volume. When I trained baristas, I taught the Americano as the simple build: one shot of espresso, then hot water up to the size you asked for.

An Americano counts as black coffee because it has no milk. It is not the same thing as a filter coffee, though, and the filter section below shows why you should not treat the two as one drink.

What Baristas and Drinkers Say

Here are six comments from real threads, quoted exactly as written, so you can see where the argument sits.

Reddit review
Long blacks come from Aus/NZ. Traditionally they tend to use more textured up dose ristretto style shots.
Mizuo___
Read this review on Reddit →
Reddit review
Long black done the Aussie way is smaller and less diluted. It's usually around 6oz size.
carameow007
Read this review on Reddit →
Reddit review
A long black is a double shot of expresso in 3-4 ounces of hot water. Americano is more diluted like one expresso in 6-8 ounces of water.
crimson230
Read this review on Reddit →
Reddit review
...a long black is only 2:1, or even 1.5:1 water:coffee, where an Americano could be anywhere from 4:1 to 8:1 water:coffee.
nzswe
Read this review on Reddit →
Reddit review
Anyone that thinks they can tell the difference, post stir, is delusional and/or pretentious
Chappell_Loam
Read this review on Reddit →
Reddit review
Not to mention the aroma is preserved too, long blacks smell nice for longer than Americanos
fudgemental
Read this review on Reddit →

Only one of the six says there is nothing to taste, and the other five name shots, size, water or aroma. You will see each of those points tested in the sections below.

The Ratio Is the Real Difference

If you want to know why the two drinks taste different, start with the arithmetic. A long black is a double shot, about 60 ml, over about 100-120 ml of water, which puts the espresso at roughly a third of the drink in your hand.

An Americano is usually one shot, about 25-30 ml, in about 120-180 ml of water. That puts the espresso at roughly one sixth to one fifth of your cup, so each sip is noticeably thinner than a long black.

That gap is why the bean shows more in a long black. With less water between you and the coffee, you taste more of what the bean brings, and the guide to what makes coffee speciality grade explains why that matters.

Add a second shot to an Americano and the espresso share rises, so the gap narrows. The names tell you the usual build, not a guarantee of what is in your cup.

Pour Order: Why Water First Keeps the Crema

Pour order is the part you have heard about, and it matters for one thing, the crema. Wikipedia's Americano entry says a long black "is made in the reverse order, by pouring an espresso shot into hot water," and that this "helps keep the espresso's crema intact."

When the espresso lands on top of the water, the crema stays on the surface where you can see and smell it. Pour water onto the espresso and you tend to break that layer up. Wikipedia's long black entry adds that both drinks keep their crema when made properly, though it is more pronounced in a long black.

Here is the honest limit. Stir either drink and most of the difference goes, which is why the sceptic on r/barista has a point. If you drink without stirring, you will notice the aroma first, as fudgemental says above, and the pour order is what gave you that.

Which Is Stronger?

A long black tastes stronger than an Americano because it uses less water, not because it has more caffeine. If you want the strongest taste of all, a short black (plain espresso with no water added) wins, and it is also the smallest drink.

An Americano is not stronger than espresso, because it is espresso diluted with water. Every ml of water you add moves the taste away from the shot you started with.

Strong can mean taste or caffeine, and the two do not move together, so decide which one you care about. Taste strength is concentration, which is where the long black has its edge. Caffeine is the next section.

Caffeine: The Shots Decide, Not the Water

If both drinks use the same number of shots, they contain the same caffeine. USDA FoodData Central lists restaurant-prepared espresso at 212 mg of caffeine per 100 g (FDC ID 171891), so a single shot of 25-30 ml gives you roughly 53-64 mg and a double shot of about 60 ml gives you roughly 127 mg, assuming 1 ml of espresso weighs about 1 g.

The water adds none to your cup. A double-shot long black and a double-shot Americano therefore match, and a single-shot Americano gives you about half the caffeine of a double-shot long black.

Here is the arithmetic in one place for you, with every caffeine figure approximate.

DrinkEspressoWater addedEspresso share of the drinkApprox. caffeine
Short black, single shot25-30 mlNoneAll of it53-64 mg
Americano, single shot25-30 ml120-180 mlAbout one sixth to one fifth53-64 mg
Long black, double shotAbout 60 mlAbout 100-120 mlAbout one thirdAbout 127 mg

For context, the European Food Safety Authority says single doses of caffeine up to 200 mg do not raise safety concerns for healthy adults. It says intakes up to 400 mg a day do not raise concerns either, except for pregnant women. That gives you a ceiling to measure your own day against.

Can You Actually Taste the Difference?

You can, but less than the internet claims and more than the sceptics admit. Drink both without stirring and the long black gives you more aroma and a more intense first sip, because the crema is still on top.

Stir them and the gap shrinks to the ratio. That ratio is still real, because you will not taste a cup that is a third espresso the same as one that is a fifth, whatever order they were poured in.

So the sceptic on r/barista and the commenter who says long blacks smell nice for longer are both partly right, and you can test both claims in your own cup. I have not run a side-by-side test for this guide, so treat that as a read of the evidence, not a result of mine.

Where the Names Come From

Both names date to the middle of the twentieth century, though neither has a tidy origin you can pin to one cafe. Wikipedia places the long black in Australia and New Zealand in the 1950s and 1960s.

Wikipedia uses 'short black' for espresso, so the long black is the longer drink made by adding water, which is the simplest reading of the name. You do not need a more romantic story than that.

The popular story for the Americano is that American soldiers in Italy during the Second World War watered down espresso with hot water. It is a good story, and you will hear it in plenty of cafes.

The Oxford English Dictionary, as reported by Wikipedia, does not support it. It traces the word to Central American Spanish 'cafe americano', a derisive term for mild coffee, from the middle of the 1950s, and its first English use to The Sunday Gleaner, a Jamaican newspaper, in 1964. You may prefer the soldiers, but the dictionary record points elsewhere.

Long Black vs Short Black, Lungo, and Filter

A short black is plain espresso, so a long black is a short black, usually doubled, with water underneath it. If a barista tells you that you wanted a short black, they mean the shot with nothing added.

A lungo is a different idea, and you should not confuse it with either drink here. It is pulled with more water through the grounds, generally twice as much as a normal espresso, which fills 25-30 ml. A lungo is pulled longer through the coffee, while an Americano adds water after the shot.

Filter coffee is brewed, not espresso. USDA lists brewed coffee at 40 mg of caffeine per 100 g against 212 mg for espresso (FDC ID 171890), but a mug of filter holds far more than a shot, so you cannot read that gap as a weaker cup. If you want to compare the brew side, the best filter coffee guide is the place to look.

How to Order a Long Black in a UK Café

If you want a long black in a UK café, describe what you want in the cup, not only the name. Ask for 'a double espresso over about 100 ml of hot water, no stir', and if that gets a blank look, ask for 'a short Americano with two shots'.

Be ready for the name not to match the cup. Some UK cafés already make Americanos with the espresso poured onto the water, and some serve a long black with as much water as an Americano, so the word on the menu does not guarantee the ratio in your cup. One barista on r/barista says most cafés now build the two the same way.

When I order one, I describe the water and let the barista pick the name. That also saves you the moment of being told you wanted a short black.

How to Make Each at Home

At home, the only thing separating the two drinks is what goes in the cup first. For a long black, you put about 100-120 ml of hot water in the cup, then pull a double shot straight on top.

For an Americano, you pull the shot first, then add about 120-180 ml of hot water per shot. Shot technique is a separate skill, and the guide to how to pull a proper espresso shot at home covers it, with espresso grind size for the day a shot tastes sour or bitter.

If your machine has no hot-water tap, the best gooseneck kettle gives you a controlled pour of hot water into the cup before the shot.

Is an Americano Healthy?

Black espresso drinks are close to calorie-free, so the drink you order is not the issue. USDA lists espresso at 9 kcal per 100 g, which makes a double shot about 5 kcal, and milk and syrups are where the calories come from.

Caffeine is the number to watch. The EFSA limits above, 400 mg a day for healthy adults, give you the ceiling, so three double-shot drinks in a day would take you close to it. The NHS says you should not have more than 200 mg of caffeine a day if you are pregnant.

I would not call any one coffee the healthiest. An Americano is one of the lightest ways you can drink espresso, because nothing is added to the shot.

Which Should You Order?

Order a long black if you want strength and bean flavour in a short, quick cup, and order an Americano if you want a longer, gentler cup to sip. Neither drink wins on everything, so here is how I weigh the choice. This is a reader-fit judgment, not a product ranking.

CriterionWeightThe question to ask yourself
Taste intensity30%Do you want the espresso loud?
Fit for the occasion25%Is this a quick cup or a long sip?
Bean expression20%Do you want to taste the coffee itself?
Crema and aroma15%Does the smell matter to you?
Value10%How much espresso are you paying for?

The less water you add, the more the bean shows, so pick a coffee you enjoy as a straight shot. I founded Balance Coffee in 2020, and Rotate Espresso is an espresso roast with dark-chocolate richness and cranberry sweetness, at £16.49 for 250g. For more choices, the guide to the best coffee beans for espresso covers the field.

Evaluation CriteriaOur Findings
Best forTasting the bean in a straight shot
RoastEspresso roast with dark-chocolate richness and cranberry sweetness
Price£16.49 for 250g
ShopShop Rotate Espresso →

This guide was updated in October 2026, and you can check every definition and limit above against the source linked in its section.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an Americano considered black coffee?

Yes. An Americano is espresso and hot water with no milk, so it counts as black coffee in the ordinary sense. It is not the same as brewed filter coffee, because it starts as espresso and is diluted afterwards, and if you add milk it is no longer black.

Is a long black just coffee and water?

Yes. A long black is a double shot of espresso poured onto hot water, and nothing else goes in the cup. What makes it a long black is the small amount of water, about 100-120 ml, and the espresso sitting on top of it, so change either and you are closer to an Americano.

Why do they call it a long black?

The name comes from Australia and New Zealand, where Wikipedia uses 'short black' for a straight espresso. Add hot water and you have a longer drink, so it is the 'long' one. Wikipedia dates the drink itself to the 1950s and 1960s, so you are ordering something with a few decades of history.

What is the difference between a long black and a short black?

A short black is a straight espresso. A long black is that espresso, usually a double, poured over about 100-120 ml of hot water. You get the same coffee in both, but the long black gives you a bigger, milder drink with the crema on top, and the short black gives you a small, concentrated one.

Is an Americano stronger than espresso?

No. An Americano is espresso diluted with hot water, so it tastes milder than the shot it started from. Its caffeine matches the shots in it because water adds none, so a single-shot Americano holds roughly 53-64 mg, the same as a single espresso you might order instead.

Is a long black the strongest coffee?

It tastes stronger than an Americano because it uses less water, but it is not stronger than an espresso, which has no water added. Caffeine depends on the number of shots, not the name. A double-shot long black holds about 127 mg, and any other double-shot drink holds the same.

What is an Americano with milk called?

Most UK cafés will make an Americano with a splash of milk if you ask, so you can order it that way. A milk-led espresso drink is a different order, and the flat white vs latte guide covers those. I would not rely on a fixed name for it, so describe what you want when you order.

Does a long black have more caffeine than an Americano?

Only if it has more shots. A double-shot long black holds about 127 mg, roughly twice the 53-64 mg in a single-shot Americano, and a double-shot Americano matches it because water adds no caffeine. Count the shots in your cup, not the name on the menu.

Can I make a long black with a capsule machine?

Yes. Run hot water into the cup first, then brew one or two espresso capsules on top, and avoid a lungo setting because it pushes more water through the coffee. The best espresso pods guide covers espresso capsules worth trying for a short, strong shot.

Comparison image: 00 americano brewing setup
Comparison image: 01 long black brewing setup
Comparison image: 02 americano finished drink
Comparison image: 03 long black finished drink
Comparison image: 04 espresso machine detail
Comparison image: 05 coffee beans and grind
James Bellis, Coffee Writer & Biohacker

Written by

James Bellis

Coffee Writer & Biohacker

A wellness entrepreneur and biohacker, James explores the intersection of hospitality and health - from clean fuel and recovery tools to mindful routines that build balance into daily life.

CoffeeFunctional DrinksBiohackingSupplementsWellness

Get access to products with our exclusive partner offers

Discounts from the brands we review. New reviews and guides worth reading. No spam.

Get up to 40% off your favourite brands.

Exclusive offers on coffee, food, health and wellness, negotiated just for you.

Unsubscribe any time.